March 19, 2012, 5:00 am

Can You Survive Google? 1 Year After The Panda Update

by: The Financial Blogger    Category: Alternative Income,Make Money Online
email this postEmail This Post Print This PostPrint This Post Post a CommentPost a Comment

 

 

~Survival of the Fittest~

Herbert Spencer

 

If you have been following The Financial Blogger for more than a year, you will remember that I was hit by the Panda update. This was an update done by Google in order to “improve” site rankings in its search engine. Some of my sites were hit hard and I lost up to 50% of my traffic on some of them. This wasn’t the first time that Google “played” with my network. In the past, I’ve been through several “Page Rank updates” (PR) where I could go from a PR4 to a PR2 or worse, a PR0 in the span of a mouse click. The Page Rank is the system used by Google to determine a site’s importance on the internet. A PR0 basically tells the world that your site doesn’t mean much in Google’s eyes. Trust me, when 2 or 3 of your biggest sites get a PR0, it’s worse than getting driven into a pillar by Zdeno Chara.

chara vs pacioretty

 

Each time I get hit by Google, I freak out. You put so much effort to please your god and it turns around and slaps you in the face. Considering that Google’s hand is the size of an elephant, that slap hurts man! I’ve been asked for help by many bloggers with regards to getting back their PR or their search engine traffic. This is why I thought about writing this article where I’ll be sharing with you most of my tricks on how to survive a “Google Apocalypse”.

 

Type of Google Apocalypses and How They Affect Your Blog

 

There are basically 2 things where Google could hit your site very hard:

#1 Search Engine Traffic:

The search engine optimization game has been in place since the internet was invented. Once Google established its supremacy in the late 90’s early 2000’s, the race for the #1 spot in Google has been the primary objective of most online marketers. Around the mid 2000’s, we saw the progression of a new type of website and Google felt for them: blogs. They offered fresh content almost daily on very specific topics.

 

This was like the perfect definition of a search engine optimized website: keyword rich with daily fresh content. Over the years, people started to make more and more money with their websites. In the Personal Finance niche, I can tell you that people were laughing at me when I told them back in 2007 that I wanted to make money online. Today, it’s a whole different ballgame where an experienced blogger can make $10,000 per month with his blogs.

 

However, while bloggers were transforming their blogs to make more and more money, the obsession with tweaking their site to please Google and rank higher reached a level close to prostitution. This is why Google decided to improve its algorithm many times throughout the years. Their most recent update was the “Panda Update” that happened in April and October of 2011. Some people saw their traffic drop by 50% in the span of a week. This is how hard Google can hit if it “deranks” your site from its search engine.

 

A blog or website, is not much without visitors. More importantly, a blog without search engine traffic cannot become a money making machine. Most loyal readers will comment on the blog and contribute to its community but will rarely click on ads. Unless you have super loyal readers in a very specific niche where there is a need, you won’t be able to sell them many things either (how many of you are making over $1,000/month with affiliate products?). Therefore, Google traffic is a gold mine for any blogger. If you don’t get that traffic, you pretty much say “goodbye” to tons of money.

 

#2 Page Rank Update:

While understanding how you can rank higher in a search engine is “relatively simple”, understanding how Page Rank (PR) works is a totally different thing. By definition, the Page Rank is a measure used by Google to determine if your site is worth something or not. New and relatively small sites usually range from PR0 to PR2. When you have an established blog, you can get a PR3 (most common), PR4 or PR5 (pretty rare). Some super lucky bloggers will reach a PR6 or PR7 but that’s incredibly rare and your chances of keeping this ranking for several years are not good.

 

Besides determining your “importance” to Google, it also determines the “power” of any links coming from your site. For example, if you have a PR3 site and you link to a PR2, you are definitely helping them and giving them a push. Your links are “worth” more than another blog that has a PR1 or PR2.

 

It is important not to mix Page Rank and Search Engine Traffic. You can have a PR4 with a lower level of traffic than a PR3 and so on. If you have a PR drop, it doesn’t mean that you will have less traffic. This is the same if you have a PR increase. Don’t get too excited, you won’t be getting many benefits from it.

 

To be honest, I’ve quit trying to understand and use this simple definition of a PR update: Google rolls the magic dice with roughly 6 sides and you get the PR on your site that way

 

Now, if you don’t offer private advertising on your blog, your PR doesn’t matter. Why? Because most people interested in your PR are advertisers who are trying to rank higher in search engines. Therefore, getting links from a PR4 blog in their niche is very powerful. As Google sets pretty much all the rules for search engines, advertisers will want to have links from high PR sites and won’t give much interest to low PR (read PR0) sites. In fact, you can get 100,000 visitors per month and have PR0, you will generate very little interest from most (read 90%) advertisers. You can always try to tell them that other metrics exist, the creators of the “other metrics” don’t operate the biggest search engine in the world.

 

Life after Google: How I’ve Survived

 

As I mentioned in the introduction, I have lost Page Rank (I once went from PR4 to PR0 on several blogs!) and been hit by the Panda update. So I’ve suffered from both Google Apocalypses… I just hope that there isn’t a third type that I haven’t discovered yet! Nonetheless, my business revenue has kept increasing throughout the years. I’ll share how to get back on track later but I want to focus on what you can do to make money blogging with less traffic or a lower PR.

 

Warning: this is not a walk in the park (and a 3,000 words article), if you don’t want to work, skip this post and forget about making money blogging ;-) .

 

#1 Forget about the “poor me” attitude:

Losing ranking sucks. Losing money sucks. But losing hope sucks even more! It’s not the time to panic or waste valuable time and energy complaining or thinking about some kind of evil conspiracy theory against your blog. Reality check: your blog is pretty small in the blogosphere (unless you are a guy like Get Rich Slowly or I Will Teach You To Be Rich ;-) ). When I say that, I’m not being arrogant. My whole network is nothing compared to the blogosphere. There are sites reaching my monthly traffic bynoon on a daily basis.

 

Repeat after me: there is no conspiracy, there is no “poor you”, it’s just a day in a real business life. The business has evolved without you, now it’s up to you to get back on your feet and evolve as well.

 

#2 Go Back To Basics:

Young blogger or experienced one, it is always good to go back to the basics once in a while. Every year or so, I read 2 of my “bibles of blogging”. It helps me to concentrate on what really matters and improve greatly my blog each time I review them. The first book is 31 Days to Build a Better Blog written by ProBlogger. This is definitely the most complete book on how to create a solid and sustainable blog. The thing I appreciate the most about this book is it includes specific tasks to achieve for each “day”. If you haven’t read this at least 3 times, you haven’t covered all blogging angles. The second book I read on a yearly basis is Blueprint for How to Make Money with a Blog by Peter Anderson @ Bibble Money Matters. While ProBlogger’s Book will teach you how to build an incredible blog with great traffic, Blueprint for How to Make Money with a Blog will focus on various ways to make money from it (including how to create your own product). Peter’s surely knows what he is doing as we replaced his wife’s income with his blogs (and he is now doing it without private advertising!). The package comes in 2 versions (PDF and an mp3 file that you can upload to your iPod). If you only want to buy one book, I think that 31 Days to Build a Better Blog is the best option.

 

#3 Focus on your readers:

First and obvious tip: focus on your readers. You might have been unfairly punished by Google and deliver great content. But the key is to continue to deliver this content. On the other hand, you should be questioning if your content is gold or not. A good trick would be to ask yourself: “would I pay $50 for this post I just wrote?”. If you wouldn’t, this is because you are not providing incredibly good content. A great article will provide a solid opinion on a specific topic with added value for the reader (e.g. things they didn’t know, a how to article or simply an article that helps people to do or understand something). These kinds of articles will get the attention of your readers and probably from other bloggers. You have a great chance of getting references and increase your readership. Your loyal readers will always help you going through tough situations.

 

#4 Work with other bloggers:

Another great way to increase your traffic is to work with other bloggers. By focusing on your readers, you will increase your direct hits. By focusing on other bloggers, you will increase your reference hits. This goes beyond asking a few friends to link towards your site. You will need several actions to generate traffic:

-          Guest posts on great blogs

-          Comment a lot

-          Submit to carnivals

-          Participate on forums

-          Help other bloggers

-          Create group project (see my Dividend Growth Index project)

Don’t underestimate the power of doing group projects. If you are able to gather 10 or so bloggers that are in your same niche, you can “share” your readers amongst the network and everybody gains.

 

I’ve asked Will Chen one of the founders of Wisebread what was his #1 trick to connect with bloggers and he told me that the best way to do it is to connect with a very few influential bloggers at a time. They can be big stars or people that you truly like (they will most likely become the next big guys anyway). Instead of commenting on 20 sites, focus on 3-4 per month. Don’t just comment, email them, share passions and interests. Build true friendships with them. Don’t just talk about blogging, become friends.

 

Some people are pretty good at working with other bloggers and are already doing it. I’m not reinventing the wheel here. So if you are doing this part perfectly, focus on the following points.

 

#5 Create a Newsletter:

I’ve written a great series on how to build your newsletter and how I made $463 in a single day with mine. This series outlines the power of a newsletter. Most people are too lazy to register to your RSS and read all your posts. It may be too much for them. However, receiving a bi-weekly newsletter is awesome for them. Especially if you provide your best content in there! The key with a newsletter is that you engage your most loyal readers to follow you all the time. You can drive traffic to your sites, start new projects, and ask them for their opinions. This has tremendous value if you want to build a real business.

 

The last part of this series (and probably the most important part) is left for my newsletter subscribers (hehehe, I know, I’m a sucker sometimes ;-) ). You can subscribe here:

 

 

 

Creating a newsletter will require additional time and it’s not easy to manage everything. On the other hand, your newsletter is one of the tools that is completely independent from Google. This is worth a lot.

 

#6 Use other ways to get traffic:

Did you know that Google wasn’t the only traffic provider? Think outside the box and try to become more active in the following channels:

-          Twitter

-          Facebook

-          YouTube (yeah I know, it’s still Google)

-          Pinterest (read this article if you doubt its power)

Social media is one of the highest sources of search results after classic search engines. If you build a reputation on social media, it will be pretty hard to be “de-ranked” from there. Social media is probably one of the most powerful platforms besides Google where you can increase your readership. If you are popular on Facebook, chances are that these people will eventually read your blog too!

 

#7 Explore different opportunities:

It’s time to open up your mind and get to the drawing board. You need to think about your blog differently. Focus on your passion and forget about the money for a while. If you know a lot about something (and you surely do), focus on that specific niche. When I say focus I mean:

-          Do keyword research (read how I use Market Samurai).

-          Create a series of articles around these keywords.

-          Don’t play keyword stuffing but rather write epic articles on specific topics with these keywords.

-          Create a small eBook or an email series to engage your audience.

-          Search for affiliates on products you use and are related to your new “niche”.

-          Once you get more traction on this niche, you can go for companies to get advertising deals.

-          Don’t build a niche site; just focus heavily on a niche within your blog.

-          This is how you become the reference in a specific domain (as I’m a reference for buying/selling blogs with TFB for example).

 

#8 Invest

: A classic reflex would be to reduce your blogging activity and your cost. After all, you are going to tell me that you won’t be going anywhere if you lose money each month, right? I’d say that you are half right, half wrong. Invest money, time and energy towards the right activities (those which create value), your blog will grow. You have been spoiled by making money easily, now you have to work to earn a buck. This is the reality of any business. If you thought that the internet or blogging was different, welcome to the real world! Change the word “spend” to “invest”. When you “spend money”, expect a return. Most people doubt in investing strategy for my online company. However, I can tell you that I’ve been growing continuously since 2008. After 4 years of aggressive investment, my expenses are now more stable while my revenues keep growing.

 

#9 Expand/Diversify:

I can never tell people often enough. Diversify your sites, your traffic sources, your income sources, diversify everything. This is the perfect way of not getting brutally hit by any storm. I’m currently running on 4 different servers for the very same reason: if one of my servers goes bust for a day, I’m not losing all my traffic, just 25% of it. There are a lot of ways you can expand your blog to a whole network and become diversified:

-          Buy other blogs

-          Build other sites

-          Create a newsletter

-          Be active on social media

-          Do a podcast

-          Create YouTube videos

-          Write an eBook

-          Create a forum or group of mastermind bloggers

-          Freelance

 

Getting Google’s Good Grace Back

 

The 3 Gs (Google’s Good Grace) is the holy trinity of the internet ;-). Getting it back is not an easy task. In fact, I don’t really know how to gain or lose the 3Gs. Getting traffic back or your Page Rank is not easy as there are no clear guidelines. This is why I focused this article on these 8 steps to survive instead of working on getting what you have lost from the very same source. Becoming more independent from the 3Gs is probably the best attitude you can have. Your blog will get a lot stronger if you do that than if you desperately work on what has been lost.

 

It doesn’t mean don’t make any changes to your site and ignore what just happened. I’ve actually learned a lot from the Panda Update (read lessons learned here). Here’s a resume of what I’ve changed since getting hit:

-          Focus on my reader’s experience

-          Work on metrics such as number of pages viewed and average time spent on site

-          Focus on getting RSS and newsletter subscribers

-          Write less articles but more powerful ones (like this one ;-) )

-          Take clear directions for each of my blogs (so readers really get what they are looking for)

-          Implement quarterly objectives to make sure we work on value added projects

-          Make sure that each site gets fresh content and with fresh incoming links all the time

 

I think that focusing on fresh content and fresh incoming links on all our sites was one of the best decisions we ever made. This is being done through various strategies:

-          Blogroll exchange

-          Carnival submissions

-          Comments on other blogs

-          Forum posting (with signatures)

-          Writing great content so you get more links towards your site

-          Highlighting other bloggers (so they are more likely to do the same in the future)

-          Create group projects (everybody links to each other and adds a lot of value for readers)

-          Write controversial posts (this always brings a lot of comments and links ;-) )

-          Guest posts

 

Unfortunately, doing all this won’t necessary get your traffic or Page Rank back from Google. On the other had, it will help you grow your traffic and make more income without being dependent on the 3Gs. If you are somewhat lucky, you will eventually get back the 3Gs on top of gaining traction from all these actions. This is how you will get stronger and become more diversified.

 

As in any kind of business, there is nothing more important than being diversified. You don’t want to be that guy whose only client is Wal-Mart.  If you lose that client, you don’t have a business anymore. This is not having a business model, this is being lucky until the perfect storm strikes.

 

The day the 3Gs pulls the plug, it sinks your blog ;-). Be independent.

 

If you have any questions, I’m here to answer on this blog!

Similar Posts:

You Want More? Sign-up! ->
TFB VIP Newsletter


If you liked this articles, you might want to sign for my FULL RSS FEEDS. If you prefer to receive the posts in your email, subscribe CLICK HERE


Comments

Very good stuff here. I have heard of the 31 Days book, but I think it is time to buy it and read it.

by: The Financial Blogger | March 19th, 2012 (8:06 am)

This is one of the very first book I read (back then, it was free or $2 I think!) but it thought me a lot about how to run my blog and make it grow. this is definitely an awesome book.

Except the police don’t investigate if your page rank goes down! :P

Great post, Mike! Thanks for sharing. Did you ever go through the request for reconsideration process, or did you just follow the steps outlined here and the PR changed on its own? I’m curious. :)

Great overview. The links to other sources are also very helpful. Thanks. One question. You state that a PR0 or PR3 blog could have way more visitors than a PR4 site. I understand. But what about natural search engine traffic. Would there be many PR3 blogs that get more natural search traffic from Google than PR4 blogs in that same niche?

another reason to keep your job while side gigging ;)

what say?

I have Peter’s book as well and found it to be really helpful as well. While I don’t hope/plan to be a full time blogger, I do want to be smart with my online ventures so that the extra income gives me the freedom to invest in even bigger businesses. You’re tips here are really helpful, TFB.

by: The Financial Blogger | March 19th, 2012 (9:46 am)

@Ottawa Guy,
yeah… that was a bit overreacting… but we are like that when it comes down to hockey ;-)

@Invest it Wisely,
sending emails to the big G is like sending emails to dead people, they rarely answer back ;-). Each time I got hit, I just refocus and work harder. I’ve never tried to communicate with them.

@Van Beek,
no, PR and traffic are totally unrelated. What I’m saying is that a PR 4 has more link power (his links worth more to Google) than a PR 0. This is why it is important to receive links from higher PR. However, I never saw any traffic movement correlated to a PR increase or PR decrease.

@Sunil,
let’s just say that it’s always better to be diversified ;-) hahaha!

@Tim,
yeah, even if you just want to build a solid sideline, you still have to consider it as a business. If not you will be getting eaten by other hardworking bloggers ;-).

Great post that brings a very good and thorough perspective on what bloggers should be focusing and working towards. GGG is important but I am a strong believer in a poweful content and networking.

Thanks Mike. I care more about freedom of expression. If Google starts dictating what I can and cannot say on the internet, then shit hits the fan.

The PR stuff is secondary. Like you said, a PR0 can get 100,000 views a month. Connecting with the community and sharing ideas is what I’m most excited about!

by: The Financial Blogger | March 19th, 2012 (11:41 am)

@Financial Samurai,
You can say what you want, it’s just that Google might not like it ;-) hahaha! it’s crazy how a company could go so big so fast and dominate its niche. I’m still using Google with my PC with Windows included ;-) hahaha!

The PR is nice but it’s not the end of the world, you can live without but you will also make less money :-(

Great tips! I’m in the process of taking my blog to the next level, so I’ll be sure to take a lot of this heart.

Cheers!

Would alexa ranking do anything to your PR rank?
This is a great post. Thanks.

I’ve been questioning lately why Google keeps the PR system in place. I know everyone says a higher PR gives you more link power, but for what? Obviously not to directly increase your SERP’s; we all know that PR isn’t well correlated with SE traffic. Maybe it is 1 out of 200 signals in the algorithm? The only people who seem to pay any attention to PR are other site owners and advertisers. So what is it really there for?

by: The Financial Blogger | March 19th, 2012 (7:14 pm)

@Passive Income
I don’t follow Alexa ranking as it’s irrelevant to me. It doesn’t affect the PR (nor anything else if you want my opinion ;-) ).

@Money Infant,
this is a very good question! but I don’t have the answer. My bet will be that if you keep asking, you will get shoot by spies ;-) lol!

Thanks for the tips! I’ve been posting comments regularly on various blogs, participated in several carnivals, and created unique content but I’m still not attracting any visitors.

Great post! Very helpful. My PR didn’t drop along with the others, thankfully. But I also know I shouldn’t depend on that.

I have noticed that backlinks from blogs and social networks are useless. Best way is to get proper links from sites that don’t normally link out, especially ones with high page rank and no social apps being used in them. Take a look at the highest ranking sites on google for highest paying keywords.. very few of them are blog sites and very few are social networks.

[...] of weird things happening lately in the PF blogosphere (it is not a coincidence that I’ve wrote how to survive Google last [...]

Thanks for all the valuable tips and ideas. I feel like a smarter blogger every time I read an article on TFB!

[...] week, I wrote a complete article on how to survive Google. This article was inspired by the huge PR slap that happened about 2 weeks ago. Last week, there [...]

Wow! That is a very comprehensive guide! I’ll be sure to checkout the two books you mentioned. Thank you for this wonderful advice!

[...] of adding excellent resources to your epic posts. About a month ago, I wrote a huge post on how to Survive Google. In this article, I explained various strategies used to create a sustainable business that is not [...]

[...] industry has moved, once again, towards another business model. I’ve discussed how I intend to survive Google. In a few weeks, my partner and I will be discussing how we will “attack” 2012-2013 (our [...]

[...] private advertisers. This represented a big risk and I knew it. In February, we had what I called The PR Slap; a new Google update penalizing many sites with private advertisers. In fact, advertisers were also [...]

[...] Google seems to have enjoyed his first kick in my face back in 2011 with the First Panda Update as it came back TWICE this year to kick me. The first time was by crashing down the private [...]

[...] #1 Can You Survive Google? [...]

[...] Can You Survive Google? 1 Year After The Panda Update – @FinancialBlogr [...]

[...] last Ice Age happened for us in early 2012 when Google struck with his minion called PANDA. Since then, my race (thefinancialusbloggerus), is starving and constantly on the move to [...]